Opportunity to drop FAT

Story: Report: Linux and USB 3.0Total Replies: 3
Author Content
bigg

Jan 19, 2010
10:13 AM EDT
As I recall, part of the problem with moving to a patent-free format for USB drives is that Windows users would have to install the drivers because Microsoft wouldn't support an alternative format. Well, this is the opportunity, as Windows users will have to install drivers for USB 3.0 anyway.
tuxchick

Jan 19, 2010
12:37 PM EDT
They'll have to install a driver for FAT64 too, so as usual MS' arguments are fibs, and swallowed by the dumb.
DrDubious

Jan 19, 2010
1:30 PM EDT
There's UDF - which already is supported on Windows XP and later as well as Mac OSX and Linux "out of the box", and which MUST have a lot of already-working "embedded" implementations available since it's also the filesystem used for DVDs.

The only limitations are the need for 3rd-party addons for XP to support WRITING to UDF (it READS fine by default, but writing to the filesystem in XP needs third-party addons. I believe it's Windows 2000 and later that includes full support by default), and the sadly abandoned state of the open-source filesystem tools (no fsck, mkudffs works fine but the documentation, at least, needs some updating).

Still quite do-able, I think, if there are enough people promoting the idea.
r_a_trip

Jan 20, 2010
5:40 AM EDT
Sadly, not going to happen. MS has already poured money around and infected the Secure Digital manufacturers with patent encumbered exFAT. We'll be subjected to crappy filesystems and an MS dependency for quite some time.

The only way to escape MS anti-competitive practises seems to be to have MS beamed into outer space by an alien spaceship.

Posting in this forum is limited to members of the group: [ForumMods, SITEADMINS, MEMBERS.]

Becoming a member of LXer is easy and free. Join Us!