No new Gartner "Analyses" since 1987

Story: Gartner: No New Unix Apps to Emerge After 2009Total Replies: 1
Author Content
phsolide

Sep 22, 2007
6:56 AM EDT
Given that ANSI C has existed in a codified state since 1989, I'd hazard that no new Unix apps have been written since then, but what do I know? Only that my Kalah game, written on a 3b2 in 1988-89 under SysV can still compile and run on Linux 2.6.23.1 today, as can a checkers game I wrote under NeXTStep in 1991-92.

Gee whiz, Mr Gartner, have you ever actually written a program for Linux or Unix or Solaris? Ever? Have you paid attention to portability issues? Cripes, I used to try to compile and test my C programs under NetBSD, Solaris (32 and 64 bit modes on SPARC) and HP-UX on their crazy PA-RISC hardware just to try to work out any pointer size assumptions or endianness kinks. It took a little work, but it wasn't THAT hard. Same as doing byacc vs bison today.

I have to conclude that Mr Gartner hasn't written a new analysis since 1987 or so, and has been COASTING ever since, slightly re-writing old analyses written when Gartner actually employed people who looked at the problem. Or, since that Golden Age may never have actually occurred, they just MAKE THINGS UP.
beirwin

Sep 22, 2007
2:53 PM EDT
Well said. I wish Gartner would fold its tent and go away. No loss except a lot of hot air.

Posting in this forum is limited to members of the group: [ForumMods, SITEADMINS, MEMBERS.]

Becoming a member of LXer is easy and free. Join Us!